Proposal for discussion · terms not yet agreed
Proposal · 109 Columbia → 557 Biscayne

A plan to move Mom and Dad once

A purchase and repayment plan for Jeff and Robin, funded until 109 Columbia Avenue sells.

Purchase loan$913,500Repaid with interest$900,000 target price plus 1.5% estimated closing costs
Renovation contribution$200,000Assumed gift · to confirmSeparate from the loan and not repaid under this proposal
Total funding requested$1,113,500Loan plus contribution. $1,163,235 if we pay the $949,000 asking price
Cash left after a $2.25M sale−$47,500ShortfallSix-month plan, after all modeled costs and repayments. A $2.5M sale leaves about $116,800.

I propose going ahead only if a conservative sale estimate and verified funds support full repayment and an agreed cash reserve. All amounts are planning estimates, not commitments.

Steve,

I would like to ask whether you would consider temporarily funding Mom and Dad’s purchase of 557 Biscayne Drive, so they can move directly into their next home while we finish renovating and selling 109 Columbia Avenue.

At a $900,000 negotiated price, the request is a $913,500 purchase loan, including estimated closing costs. That is separate from the roughly $200,000 you have discussed providing for renovations. Mom and Dad would buy and own Biscayne directly and repay your purchase loan, plus agreed interest, from the Columbia sale. This proposal assumes the renovation contribution is a gift, which we would confirm with you.

Why this move, and why this timing

Buying before selling lets Mom and Dad move once

We’ve toured Biscayne together. Buying it first avoids a temporary rental and a second move, and leaves Columbia empty for the final work, staging and marketing that should help it sell well.

  • One planned move

    Jeff and Robin go straight from Columbia to Biscayne. No interim rental, no storage, no second packing-up.

  • Columbia ready to show

    A vacant house lets the crew finish the last work quickly and lets us stage and market it properly.

  • A clear repayment event

    Your loan is repaid through escrow when Columbia closes. The sale proceeds are the source of repayment.

  • A defined budget and time limit

    A target loan of $913,500, an agreed renovation budget, and repayment at the sale or 12 months, whichever comes first.

How the timing would work

Mom and Dad expect to stay at Columbia for the first one to two months of work. We would try to time the Biscayne purchase for when they need to leave, subject to the seller’s timing. [3]

This schedule is proposed. It depends on the construction schedule, the Biscayne negotiation and escrow timing. See the timeline.

The two properties

One home to finish and sell, one to buy

Renovate and sell

109 Columbia Avenue

Mill Valley · Jeff and Robin’s current home

Original purchase
$408,000
Completed work
$169,000
Planned work
$200,000
Mortgage balances
$1,035,890

Family estimate of renovated value: $2.3–$2.5 million. This is our estimate, not a valuation; we need an agent’s conservative opinion of value before relying on it. [3]

Proposed replacement home

557 Biscayne Drive

San Rafael 94901 · Peacock Estates townhome · MLS #326077317

Asking price
$949,000
Our target
$900,000
Size
1,848 sq ft
Bedrooms
2 + loft
Bathrooms
2.5
Garage
Detached, 2-car
HOA dues
$890/mo
Built
1989

The listing describes an updated kitchen and bathrooms. HOA dues are $10,680 a year, plus property tax, insurance and other ownership costs. [1, 2]

Tour the home

Walk through 557 Biscayne

We toured Biscayne in October. This silent walkthrough (4 min) combines our own videos, the listing photos and the key numbers. Jump to any part using the list.

    Listing photos marked “staged” show furniture that does not come with the home.

    Funding and repayment

    A purchase loan that is repaid, and a renovation gift that is not

    The request has two parts. They are documented separately and treated differently.

    Loan · repaid$913,500Purchase loan from Steve

    Paid through escrow to buy Biscayne at the $900,000 target, including about $13,500 in closing costs. Jeff and Robin own Biscayne directly.

    Assumed gift · not repaid$200,000Renovation contribution

    Funds the planned work at Columbia. If it turns out to be repayable, every cash figure falls by $200,000 plus any agreed interest.

    Repayment source$932,912Paid back at Columbia’s closing

    Principal plus about $19,412 interest at six months ($38,824 at twelve), paid from sale proceeds after the mortgages.

    Use of fundsTarget purchaseAt asking price
    Biscayne purchase$900,000$949,000
    Estimated closing costs (1.5%)$13,500$14,235
    Purchase loan to be repaid$913,500$963,235
    Separate proposed renovation gift$200,000$200,000
    Total funding from Steve$1,113,500$1,163,235

    The $900,000 target is subject to negotiation, and a cash offer doesn’t guarantee a discount. A higher price or any extra advance would need a revised budget and your agreement. [1]

    Interest is modeled at 4.25% simple, using the October 2026 IRS short-term rate as a benchmark. That rate is an illustration; the actual rate and its tax treatment would be agreed before signing. [4]

    No equity cushion in Biscayne at the start

    The loan equals 101.5% of the purchase price, so Biscayne alone offers no initial equity cushion. Counsel should evaluate Columbia as additional collateral, subject to its existing mortgages and liens. Security does not guarantee repayment. [8]

    Proposed terms, for discussion

    A starting point. We would agree on these with you and have a California real estate attorney and CPA review them before committing funds.

    Ownership and funding

    Mom and Dad buy and own Biscayne directly. You lend the approved purchase price and closing costs through escrow, with $913,500 as the target loan. The renovation gift is documented separately.

    Repayment

    At the Columbia sale closing or twelve months, whichever comes first, with interest paid at payoff and no prepayment penalty. The rate is agreed before signing; 4.25% is an illustration. Any extension needs a new written agreement.

    Security

    Counsel prepares a promissory note and appropriate recorded security, reviews lien priority and sets escrow payoff instructions. The loan equals 101.5% of the purchase price, so Biscayne alone offers no initial equity cushion. Counsel should evaluate Columbia as additional collateral, subject to existing mortgages and liens. Security does not guarantee repayment. [8]

    Funding limit and updates

    We agree on your maximum commitment, the renovation budget, a target listing date and monthly updates. Any additional advance needs your separate agreement. The plan must fit your liquidity needs if the loan runs the full term.

    Repayment and cash remaining

    What each Columbia sale leaves Jeff and Robin

    The family estimates Columbia’s renovated value at $2.3 million to $2.5 million; we need an agent’s conservative valuation before relying on that range. The chart includes lower outcomes so we can see where more funds would be needed. [3]

    Columbia saleNet long-term gainModeled sale taxesCash after 6 monthsCash after 12 months

    Cash deducts a 6% selling-cost allowance, $1,035,890 for Columbia mortgages, $40,000 to Maddy, the $913,500 Biscayne loan, modeled taxes, loan interest and $50,000 for other costs (moving, carrying costs and overruns, held constant at twelve months). The renovation gift is not repaid. Final lender payoff statements may differ. Figures rounded to $100. Trust and business cash flows belong in the separate household budget. [3]

    Interest and the purchase price

    Interest is modeled at 4.25% simple annual interest, the October 2026 IRS short-term benchmark. On the target loan that is about $19,412 for six months or $38,824 for twelve. The agreed rate and tax treatment must fit the note’s actual date and terms. [4]

    Columbia sale$900K purchase, 6 months$949K purchase, 6 months$949K purchase, 12 months
    $2,250,000−$47,500−$98,300−$118,800
    $2,400,000$53,900$3,100−$17,400
    $2,500,000$116,800$66,100$45,600

    Buying at asking reduces six-month cash by about $50,800. At a $2.4 million Columbia sale, paying $949,000 leaves only about $3,100 after six months.

    Proposed cash reserve: $100,000. Keeping it at the $900K target price requires about a $2.474M Columbia sale after six months, or $2.505M after twelve. Before committing, we would verify repayment and the reserve using the actual tax estimate and budget. If the $200,000 renovation contribution is repayable, subtract another $200,000 plus any agreed interest from these balances.

    Renovation and timeline

    What’s done, what’s planned, and the order of events

    The sequence below is proposed. Dates depend on the contractor’s schedule, the Biscayne negotiation and escrow. Nothing has been scheduled or signed.

    Completed$169,000

    Work already done at Columbia

    Kitchen, dining and living room, deck, roof and bathroom renovations, assumed to include Maddy’s prior work. Documentation is needed for the tax basis. [3]

    Planned · estimate$200,000

    Additional qualifying renovation

    Funded by the proposed renovation gift. Scope, contractor budget and schedule are not yet final. The work should add enough value to justify its cost, and the full amount must be spent to count toward basis. [10]

    1. Before committing

      Verify, then agree terms

      Conservative Columbia values, an itemized contractor budget and schedule, Biscayne disclosures and HOA documents, and a CPA tax estimate. Then agree the funding limit, loan terms and cash reserve with you.

    2. Month 0

      Buy Biscayne

      Your loan funds the purchase through escrow; Jeff and Robin take title. Timed, as far as the seller allows, to when they need to leave Columbia.

    3. Months 1–2 of work

      Renovation starts with Mom and Dad still at Columbia

      They expect to stay for the first one to two months of work.

    4. Then

      One move

      Jeff and Robin move into Biscayne. Columbia is left vacant.

    5. Following months

      Finish, stage and list Columbia

      Final work, staging and marketing toward an agreed target listing date, with monthly updates to you.

    6. Sale or month 12

      Columbia closes and escrow pays off

      Mortgages, your loan with interest, and Maddy are paid; taxes are set aside; the agreed reserve is kept. Repayment is due at closing or twelve months, whichever comes first.

    Tax assumptions

    How the sale is taxed

    Taxable gain

    Sale price after selling costs, minus the tax basis, minus the home-sale exclusion and capital losses. Mortgages don’t reduce it.

    Cash remaining

    What’s left after selling costs, mortgage payoffs, Maddy, your loan and interest, taxes and the cost allowance.

    Property equity

    Value in a home beyond its debt. Biscayne starts with none of its own, since the loan is 101.5% of its price.

    The estimate uses the family’s purchase cost, renovations, capital losses and expected income. Mortgage repayments affect cash proceeds, not the gain. These are 2026 planning figures; the CPA must confirm the actual closing year, deductions and available losses. [3, 10, 12–18]

    Adjusted basis inputAmount
    Original purchase price (includes the $80,000 down payment)$408,000
    Completed kitchen, dining and living room, deck, roof and bathroom renovations$169,000
    Planned additional qualifying renovations$200,000
    Modeled adjusted tax basis$777,000

    The $169,000 is assumed to include Maddy’s prior work. All $369,000 of improvements must qualify, be documented and remain part of the home at sale; the proposed $200,000 must actually be spent. The model applies the full $500,000 married home-sale exclusion and $330,000 of remaining long-term capital losses (federal and California). Other sale-year income is $15,000 of taxable trust income less a $20,000 business loss, a net −$5,000. [3, 10, 16–18]

    Worked example: Columbia sells for $2,250,000
    CalculationAmount
    Sale after the 6% selling-cost allowance$2,115,000
    Gain after subtracting the $777,000 basis$1,338,000
    Net long-term gain after $500,000 exclusion and $330,000 losses$508,000
    Adjusted gross income after the net $5,000 ordinary loss$503,000
    Federal taxable income after the $32,200 standard deduction$470,800
    Regular federal tax at capital-gain rates$55,785
    Federal net investment income tax$9,614
    California regular income tax before credits$38,317
    Combined modeled sale tax$103,716

    Federal taxable income includes $98,900 at 0% and $371,900 at 15%, none at 20%. NIIT is 3.8% of $253,000. California uses graduated rates and an $11,800 joint standard deduction. The trust’s reporting must confirm the taxable amount and character, and the business loss must be deductible in the sale year. Assumes no rental depreciation or other capital transactions; excludes itemization, age-related deductions, credits and other adjustments. Treats the 6% allowance as eligible selling costs. [10, 12–15, 17, 18]

    Neighborhood evidence

    Price context for a $900K offer

    $995,000Original list, Sep 11
    $949,000Reduced Oct 13
    $900,000Our target, if supported

    The $949,000 asking price follows a $46,000 cut from $995,000 in mid-October. A $900,000 target is $49,000, or about 5.2%, below asking. An offer would need the agent’s analysis behind it; a cash closing does not assure that discount. [1]

    Recent nearby townhome saleClosedBeds / bathsSq ftSale pricePer sq ft
    125 Knollwood Drive [5]Jul 20, 20262 / 21,865$899,000$482
    15 Sulgrave Lane [6]Sep 30, 20263 / 31,694$955,000$564
    143 Knollwood Drive [7]May 6, 20263 / 21,900$1,152,000$606
    557 Biscayne Drive (asking)Listed Sep 11, 20262 + loft / 2.51,848$949,000$514

    These are nearby examples, not an appraisal or completed comparative market analysis. None is verified as a sale within Biscayne’s 12-unit association. Bedrooms, condition, views, layout, sale date and HOA obligations all need adjustment. The similar-sized two-bedroom sale at $899,000 is useful context for the target price.

    Aerial map of the Biscayne townhome cluster with value labels
    Townhome cluster on Biscayne Drive. Map labels range from $985,000 to $1.87 million. They are unverified map values with no stated method or date, and do not establish Biscayne’s value. The heart marker and nearby $1.14M label are not a valuation of 557. [3]
    Wider aerial map showing open space and detached homes along Biscayne Drive
    Surrounding neighborhood. The cluster sits beside open space and detached homes labeled roughly $3.82 million to $6.19 million. Those homes differ in size, land and ownership responsibilities; the labels are setting context, not comparable sales. [3]
    Open decisions and next steps

    What we’d settle together before committing

    1. Confirm your gift and loan terms

      Open

      Whether the $200,000 is a gift, your maximum commitment, the interest rate, the twelve-month limit and any extension terms.

    2. Get a supported Columbia valuation

      Open

      Conservative as-is and renovated values from an agent, before relying on the $2.3–2.5 million family range.

    3. Finalize the renovation budget and schedule

      Open

      An itemized contractor budget, a realistic schedule and a target listing date.

    4. Review Biscayne disclosures and HOA documents

      In progress

      Inspections, reserves, budgets, board minutes, insurance, assessments and responsibility for major repairs. We’re obtaining these now; no defect or assessment is assumed. [11]

    5. Confirm tax assumptions and lender payoffs

      Open

      CPA review of basis, exclusion, capital losses, trust income and business loss for the actual sale year; lender payoff statements; Proposition 19 eligibility and property taxes during the overlap. [9]

    6. Identify funds for costs before Columbia closes

      Open

      Moving, carrying costs and overruns before the sale. The $50,000 allowance is an expense estimate, not an additional advance assumed from you.

    7. Agree the reserve target and a fallback plan

      Open

      A minimum cash reserve and verified funds for any shortfall. If needed, lower the purchase budget, or use temporary housing and sell Columbia first.

    Would you be open to talking this through?

    We could review the valuation, contractor budget, disclosures and tax estimate together, then agree on the funding limit, loan terms and cash reserve before anyone makes a purchase commitment.

    Thank you for considering this. My goal is to help Mom and Dad make one manageable move, and to give you a clear picture of how the funding and repayment would work.

    Jake

    Sources and assumptions

    Listing, sale and tax sources checked October 28, 2026. Family inputs remain estimates. Tax calculations use 2026 rules and should be updated for the actual closing year. Amounts and dates are planning assumptions, not commitments or guaranteed outcomes.

    1. Compass listing for 557 Biscayne Drive and price history
    2. MLSListings current record 326077317
    3. Family financial figures and neighborhood screenshots supplied October 28, 2026
    4. IRS Revenue Ruling 2026-19, October 2026 interest benchmarks
    5. Redfin closed sale for 125 Knollwood Drive
    6. myTheo MLS closed sale for 15 Sulgrave Lane
    7. Tuscana Properties closed sale for 143 Knollwood Drive
    8. California DRE guidance on trust deed lending
    9. California BOE Proposition 19 replacement residence guidance
    10. IRS Publication 523, Selling Your Home
    11. California DRE August 2026 HOA disclosure guidance
    12. IRS 2026 capital gain brackets and standard deductions
    13. IRS Publication 505 capital gain tax worksheet for 2026
    14. IRS Net Investment Income Tax
    15. California FTB October 2026 tax brackets and deductions
    16. IRS Publication 550, capital loss carryforwards
    17. IRS trust beneficiary Schedule K-1 instructions
    18. IRS Publication 334, business loss deductions

    Private family proposal. Prepared for Steve by Jake Zimmerman. Please don’t forward without asking. Not legal, tax or investment advice; the arrangement needs review by a California real estate attorney and a CPA.

    Tour video: family walkthrough footage from October 2026 and listing photos from the Compass/MLS listing.